April 1, 2024. Bulkagram 26, Welcome to the FY 24-25!
This presentation has been reproduced as part of the proceedings of Mr. Balan Velan’s discourse on Dense Phase Power Optimisation at the Chicago Powder Show. If you own a dense phase system, it will save you 30% of your OPEX costs to do a simple power optimisation. If your plant does the power op program, you can find out EXACTLY how much power your system needs versus power used. Interested? Let us know in the comments below!
The short answer
Most plants don’t know. The power it takes to convey 1 tonne per hour of a powder depends on four things: the product, the capacity, the conveying distance and, above all, how much air the system uses. In a dense phase system the compressor is the bulk of the operating cost, and every cubic metre of air beyond what the material needs is power paid for and wasted. The only way to know your number is to measure it, in kW per tonne conveyed.
Why dense phase systems use more power than they need
Dense phase conveying moves material through the pipe as a non-suspended flow, and the ratio of material to air decides how efficiently it uses energy. When the ratio is wrong, the compressor supplies more air than the material needs. The usual cause is a vessel that is simply filled, pressurised and opened, with nothing controlling the air once the discharge valve opens: the whole mass of air and product bursts into the line and pushes one long plug of material, which takes a high starting pressure.
If the air is released in timed pulses instead, the material travels as several short plugs separated by air. Short plugs need much less pressure to move than one long plug of the same total length, so the same tonnage moves with less air and less power. For plants that run dense phase conveying round the clock, a simple power optimisation can take up to 30% off operating costs.
How to work out your own number
- Measure the air. Compressed air flow into the vessel and total compressed air used, in m³/h.
- Measure the material. Bulk solids flow, in kg/h, plus line pressure at the start and end of the conveying line.
- Compare. From these, calculate the material-to-air ratio and the power used in kW per tonne. Compare it with what the duty needs and with what the rest of the industry uses for the same product.
Typical figures: dense phase vs dilute phase
| Dense phase | Dilute phase | |
|---|---|---|
| Phase density (kg material per kg air) | 10 to over 100 | Under 10, typically 4–6 |
| Conveying velocity | 3–10 m/s | 20–30 m/s |
| Conveying pressure | 2–6 bar | Up to 1 bar |
The higher the phase density, the less air each tonne needs. That is why the same duty can draw very different power depending on how the system is designed and run.
Measure it, then fix it
Scorpio’s power OP dense phase power optimiser does both. The power optimisation program fits instruments and data logging to your conveying line, permanently or for an audit, and reports real-time kW per tonne against the material actually conveyed. The power OP controller then pulses the conveying air so material moves as short plugs at lower pressure, cutting power consumption by up to 30%. It retrofits to any dense phase pressure vessel, and is a built-in option on the powderPUMP modular dense phase conveyor.
For the basics of the method, see dense phase pneumatic conveying. To find out what your own system should be using, tell us your product, capacity and line length.